Skip to main content

Table 1 Morphologic comparison of synovial structure, cellularity, macrophage content, and bone marrow involvement between the Dual-Modular Neck and the Metal-on-Metal (MoM) total hip arthroplasty (THA) groups

From: Implant based differences in adverse local tissue reaction in failed total hip arthroplasties: a morphological and immunohistochemical study

Morphologic characteristic

Dual-Modular Neck THA (N = 55 hips)

MoM THA (N = 18 hips)

P value

Synovial structure

Cases (%)

Cases (%)

 

Synovial layer loss

96.4

100.0

 

Synovial layer hyperplasia

78.2

77.8

 

Cell exfoliation

87.3

94.4

 

Necrosis

65.5

61.1

 

Vascular wall changes

18.2

16.7

 

High endothelial cell venules

14.5

16.7

 

Granulomas

18.2

11.1

0.482

Cellularity

   

Macrophages

  

0.016*

  Grade 1

16.4

5.6

 

  Grade 2

30.9

5.6

 

  Grade 3

50.9

88.9

 

Lymphocytes

  

0.066#

  Grade 1

1.8

16.7

 

  Grade 2

9.1

5.6

 

  Grade 3

52.7

61.1

 

  Grade 4

34.5

16.7

 

Stromal Cells

  

0.593

  Grade 1

27.3

38.9

 

  Grade 2

50.9

44.4

 

  Grade 3

16.4

11.1

 

Neutrophils

10.9

11.1

 

Plasma cells sparse

32.7

38.9

 

Plasma cells numerous

20.0

22.2

 

Eosinophils

32.7

33.3

 

Macrophage content

   

Polyethylene particles

1.8

0.0

 

Metallic particles

1.8

33.3

<0.005*

Corrosion products

100

100

 

  Intracellular distribution

Sparse

Diffuse

 

  Intracellular morphology

Irregular

Globular + Irregular

 

Extracellular corrosion aggregates

72.7

66.7

0.662

Bone/bone marrow

   

Necrosis

47.1

28.6

 

Macrophage infiltration

47.1

100.0

 

Benign lymphocytic aggregates

35.3

28.6

 

Germinal centers

17.6

0.0

 
  1. *Statistically significant at p < 0.05 for Dual-Modular Neck versus MoM THA. #trend towards statistical significance p < 0.10 for Dual-Modular Neck versus MoM THA.
  2. Morphologic Characteristics of Synovial Tissue from Dual-Modular Neck and MoM THA Groups.